Friday, May 23, 2014

Conclusion

This post marks the final analysis on the usability of magic and how helpful/harmful it can be. Honestly, it was quite a bit of work, tallying up the points each side of magic has. In just a few sentences, you will find out which side to take on the matter. After reviewing the many uses of magic throughout the series, I have come, indeed, to a conclusion.

Magic is advantageous. Easily. Despite the many problems it can bring up, magic is obviously advantageous. Why did I choose this, you may wonder. Were you rooting for the other choice? Are you still leaning towards the disadvantages? Perhaps this will convince you.


  • Magic amplifies select characters, giving them new abilities. Without magic, Eragon would have been dead if he tried to face King Galbatorix. He could have have been dead before then. The Blood-oath Celebration among the elves changed him physically and mentally. He was more confident, having a better grasp of the world and had better physical skill with a sword/running. The magic of the celebration also helped him use magic much more effortlessly and easily. He crushed enemies which seemed to be such a great challenge before. This key component of the story led to the eventual defeat of the king.
  • Magic can rework difficult situations, particularly treachery. This may sound weird, but it is actually true. Looking back at Sloan, Katrina's father who betrayed them to the Ra'zac in order to prevent Katrina from marrying Roran. He was captured by the Ra'zac and when rescued, spared by Eragon. Eragon didn't want Katrina or Roran to know, so he cursed Sloan so he could never see them again. Eragon sent him to the home of the elves in order to  reforge Sloan's identity, making himself a new person if he wanted. Sloan was very angry and discontent, but it was actually for his own good. Magic helps here because it is punishing yet forgiving, able to change people from their past ways into someone new.    

Friday, May 9, 2014

Is Magic What It Appears To Be? #7

To me, this title directly represents this use of magic in the final installment of the Inheritance cycle, Inheritance. Apparently the sky's the limit for magic at this point. As we have viewed in Brisingr and even back to Eldest, magic can control people and destroy people and blind people and curse people and even transform people. But trick people? I don't think so. If an enemy magician is strong enough, it is barely even possible to trick someone. No, don't get me wrong, tricking people happens all of the time in this series. Sloan, Katrina's betrayer and father, was claimed dead by Eragon in order to fool Roran. Are you wondering how Murtagh, Eragon's friend, became so powerful (Post #2) that he crushed him at the next battle? Not by will. He was forcibly taken to Galbatorix by two elusive magicians named the Twins who tricked Eragon into thinking he was dead.

This sort of tricking deals with illusions and the magician behind them, Carn. During a battle to capture an important city of the Empire, Aroughs, Roran and his troops are outnumbered, with only 800 troops to face more than 1600. I know as well as you do; 2:1 is no small ratio to pass over. Another problem is that a lot of Roran's troops are wounded. What Carn does is tricky in nature; illusions could ultimately save him and the others from discovery but in return, kill him for lack of energy. He creates a fire with only Roran sitting there, cloaking the men and the camps. Carn manages to pull it off, but not without a fierce battle with a curious Empire magician, driving away them away. The battle ensued when "the hook-nosed spellcaster behind him, whose complexion, Roran noticed, had acquired a deathly cast in the brief span since Tharos had set his foot on the ground. Tharos must have noticed the change in his magician as well, for his own expression became strained." (Paolini 152). When a magician becomes pale, he is either a) becoming tired, or b) fighting another magician. The hook-nosed person couldn't have been tired; he just got there! Carn was just applying his impressive display of magic to crush his outwardly opportunistic opponent.

So the bottom line is, magic is resourceful for various reasons; it helps the Varden escape death at the hands of Galbatorix, it gives Carn a chance to defeat the other magician, and it confuses the enemy, buying Roran more time to capture the city.

To the right is the author, Christopher Paolini, during the launch of Inheritance on November 8th, 2011.      

Sunday, May 4, 2014

Is Magic What It Appears To Be? #6

Right now, you're probably thinking I just overdid it. I passed my mark. Maybe I rambled on and on too much about one thing. Maybe you're bored. Maybe you think I'm very repetitive.

This second to last post concerns, at last, an few advantages of magic. No disadvantages here. This is a strictly advantageous conversation.

Magic, in this series alone, can be applied with the mind. Telepathic communication (non-verbal), mind control, and the attacking/defending of one's mind can be achieved with this. As this information frequently shows itself during the story line, different uses of it is also present. When Eragon must construct a new sword, made with magic since his last blade (Post #5) shattered, he must confront an old sword smith named Rhunön. Because of her magical oath not to craft another sword for anyone, she couldn't break her oath to Eragon to help him. She had to enter his mind and control him to construct the sword. It was dangerous and could have killed both of them, but the power of magic held, allowing Eragon to get a new sword without forcing Rhunön to try and break her oath. His feelings are portrayed with imagery and a little metaphor in this paragraph; "It felt to Eragon like a piece of raw wool sliding over his skin as Rhunön enveloped his mind with hers, insinuating herself into the most private areas of his being. He shivered at the contact and almost withdrew from it, but then Rhunön's rough vioce sounded within his skull......" (Paolini 668). The abilities and strength of magic here makes it super advantageous, especially for Eragon, because he gets a sword made by one of the best smiths among the elves.

Another advantage of magic is in combat. Spirits exist in this story, and when they are controlled by a person, the person becomes a Shade. Shades are mostly evil, especially Varaug, the Shade in charge of Belatona, an important Empire city. Shades can only be killed by stabbing through the heart, and because of magic, this was possible for Eragon and Arya. Eragon used magic to briefly attack the Shade's mind, catching him off guard. ".....he resumed his attack on the Shade's consciousness, his only thought to restrain the Shade for a few moments. Varaug rose onto one knee, then faltered as Eragon redoubled his efforts." (Paolini 738). The magic spared time they could have lost if the Shade had gotten back up on his feet. I think the Shade was plenty powerful and it was rare to defeat a Shade, but recently Shades have had their all time high of death, Durza, then Varaug. Two deaths is a lot for the entire class of Shades, which may only be 5 or 6. Magic, if it can best and kill off yet another Shade, then it is definitely advantageous.

To the right is a past trailer of Eragon. To me the movie had its highs and lows, but you may think differently.