Magic is advantageous. Easily. Despite the many problems it can bring up, magic is obviously advantageous. Why did I choose this, you may wonder. Were you rooting for the other choice? Are you still leaning towards the disadvantages? Perhaps this will convince you.
- Magic amplifies select characters, giving them new abilities. Without magic, Eragon would have been dead if he tried to face King Galbatorix. He could have have been dead before then. The Blood-oath Celebration among the elves changed him physically and mentally. He was more confident, having a better grasp of the world and had better physical skill with a sword/running. The magic of the celebration also helped him use magic much more effortlessly and easily. He crushed enemies which seemed to be such a great challenge before. This key component of the story led to the eventual defeat of the king.
- Magic can rework difficult situations, particularly treachery. This may sound weird, but it is actually true. Looking back at Sloan, Katrina's father who betrayed them to the Ra'zac in order to prevent Katrina from marrying Roran. He was captured by the Ra'zac and when rescued, spared by Eragon. Eragon didn't want Katrina or Roran to know, so he cursed Sloan so he could never see them again. Eragon sent him to the home of the elves in order to reforge Sloan's identity, making himself a new person if he wanted. Sloan was very angry and discontent, but it was actually for his own good. Magic helps here because it is punishing yet forgiving, able to change people from their past ways into someone new.