Friday, May 23, 2014

Conclusion

This post marks the final analysis on the usability of magic and how helpful/harmful it can be. Honestly, it was quite a bit of work, tallying up the points each side of magic has. In just a few sentences, you will find out which side to take on the matter. After reviewing the many uses of magic throughout the series, I have come, indeed, to a conclusion.

Magic is advantageous. Easily. Despite the many problems it can bring up, magic is obviously advantageous. Why did I choose this, you may wonder. Were you rooting for the other choice? Are you still leaning towards the disadvantages? Perhaps this will convince you.


  • Magic amplifies select characters, giving them new abilities. Without magic, Eragon would have been dead if he tried to face King Galbatorix. He could have have been dead before then. The Blood-oath Celebration among the elves changed him physically and mentally. He was more confident, having a better grasp of the world and had better physical skill with a sword/running. The magic of the celebration also helped him use magic much more effortlessly and easily. He crushed enemies which seemed to be such a great challenge before. This key component of the story led to the eventual defeat of the king.
  • Magic can rework difficult situations, particularly treachery. This may sound weird, but it is actually true. Looking back at Sloan, Katrina's father who betrayed them to the Ra'zac in order to prevent Katrina from marrying Roran. He was captured by the Ra'zac and when rescued, spared by Eragon. Eragon didn't want Katrina or Roran to know, so he cursed Sloan so he could never see them again. Eragon sent him to the home of the elves in order to  reforge Sloan's identity, making himself a new person if he wanted. Sloan was very angry and discontent, but it was actually for his own good. Magic helps here because it is punishing yet forgiving, able to change people from their past ways into someone new.    

Friday, May 9, 2014

Is Magic What It Appears To Be? #7

To me, this title directly represents this use of magic in the final installment of the Inheritance cycle, Inheritance. Apparently the sky's the limit for magic at this point. As we have viewed in Brisingr and even back to Eldest, magic can control people and destroy people and blind people and curse people and even transform people. But trick people? I don't think so. If an enemy magician is strong enough, it is barely even possible to trick someone. No, don't get me wrong, tricking people happens all of the time in this series. Sloan, Katrina's betrayer and father, was claimed dead by Eragon in order to fool Roran. Are you wondering how Murtagh, Eragon's friend, became so powerful (Post #2) that he crushed him at the next battle? Not by will. He was forcibly taken to Galbatorix by two elusive magicians named the Twins who tricked Eragon into thinking he was dead.

This sort of tricking deals with illusions and the magician behind them, Carn. During a battle to capture an important city of the Empire, Aroughs, Roran and his troops are outnumbered, with only 800 troops to face more than 1600. I know as well as you do; 2:1 is no small ratio to pass over. Another problem is that a lot of Roran's troops are wounded. What Carn does is tricky in nature; illusions could ultimately save him and the others from discovery but in return, kill him for lack of energy. He creates a fire with only Roran sitting there, cloaking the men and the camps. Carn manages to pull it off, but not without a fierce battle with a curious Empire magician, driving away them away. The battle ensued when "the hook-nosed spellcaster behind him, whose complexion, Roran noticed, had acquired a deathly cast in the brief span since Tharos had set his foot on the ground. Tharos must have noticed the change in his magician as well, for his own expression became strained." (Paolini 152). When a magician becomes pale, he is either a) becoming tired, or b) fighting another magician. The hook-nosed person couldn't have been tired; he just got there! Carn was just applying his impressive display of magic to crush his outwardly opportunistic opponent.

So the bottom line is, magic is resourceful for various reasons; it helps the Varden escape death at the hands of Galbatorix, it gives Carn a chance to defeat the other magician, and it confuses the enemy, buying Roran more time to capture the city.

To the right is the author, Christopher Paolini, during the launch of Inheritance on November 8th, 2011.      

Sunday, May 4, 2014

Is Magic What It Appears To Be? #6

Right now, you're probably thinking I just overdid it. I passed my mark. Maybe I rambled on and on too much about one thing. Maybe you're bored. Maybe you think I'm very repetitive.

This second to last post concerns, at last, an few advantages of magic. No disadvantages here. This is a strictly advantageous conversation.

Magic, in this series alone, can be applied with the mind. Telepathic communication (non-verbal), mind control, and the attacking/defending of one's mind can be achieved with this. As this information frequently shows itself during the story line, different uses of it is also present. When Eragon must construct a new sword, made with magic since his last blade (Post #5) shattered, he must confront an old sword smith named Rhunön. Because of her magical oath not to craft another sword for anyone, she couldn't break her oath to Eragon to help him. She had to enter his mind and control him to construct the sword. It was dangerous and could have killed both of them, but the power of magic held, allowing Eragon to get a new sword without forcing Rhunön to try and break her oath. His feelings are portrayed with imagery and a little metaphor in this paragraph; "It felt to Eragon like a piece of raw wool sliding over his skin as Rhunön enveloped his mind with hers, insinuating herself into the most private areas of his being. He shivered at the contact and almost withdrew from it, but then Rhunön's rough vioce sounded within his skull......" (Paolini 668). The abilities and strength of magic here makes it super advantageous, especially for Eragon, because he gets a sword made by one of the best smiths among the elves.

Another advantage of magic is in combat. Spirits exist in this story, and when they are controlled by a person, the person becomes a Shade. Shades are mostly evil, especially Varaug, the Shade in charge of Belatona, an important Empire city. Shades can only be killed by stabbing through the heart, and because of magic, this was possible for Eragon and Arya. Eragon used magic to briefly attack the Shade's mind, catching him off guard. ".....he resumed his attack on the Shade's consciousness, his only thought to restrain the Shade for a few moments. Varaug rose onto one knee, then faltered as Eragon redoubled his efforts." (Paolini 738). The magic spared time they could have lost if the Shade had gotten back up on his feet. I think the Shade was plenty powerful and it was rare to defeat a Shade, but recently Shades have had their all time high of death, Durza, then Varaug. Two deaths is a lot for the entire class of Shades, which may only be 5 or 6. Magic, if it can best and kill off yet another Shade, then it is definitely advantageous.

To the right is a past trailer of Eragon. To me the movie had its highs and lows, but you may think differently.  

Saturday, April 26, 2014

Is Magic What It Appears To Be? #5

This third to last post about the benefits and costly ramifications of magic explores the various situations in which magic is used. Magic, as portrayed in Brisingr, is most effective when the enemy doesn't know the art of magic use. But like other fighting tools, like the mind and the sword, magic can sometimes fail in the presence of other skilled magicians. Eragon experiences this when he face enemy dwarves from an enemy clan, Az Sweldn rak Anhûin. He believed that he could take down the dwarves easily since he was partially elvish, but in my opinion, that fact came right back around to stab him in the back. A backstabbing reality, you could say.

You see, Eragon didn't expect the dwarves to be more skilled and faster than the average dwarf warrior. This shows that he might have not considered dwarf warriors to be a challenge, maybe a little underestimation. "Two of the black-garbed dwarves rushed him, stabbing at his belly with their blood-hungry daggers. Sword in hand, Eragon parried both blows, stunned by the dwarves' speed and ferocity." (Paolini 450). When his wards, or magical surroundings/shields failed, he was again surprised at the agility the dwarves possessed. "A breath of wind tickled his neck as the tip of a dagger whipped past his throat. Another blade tugged at the cuff of his leggings, cutting them open. He flinched and swung the falchion, trying to gain space to fight. My wards should have turned their blades away! he thought, bewildered." (Paolini 451).

Clearly the magical wards Eragon put in place failed, conveniently, right when he is fighting fierce warriors. But that's not all that magic leaves him behind with. Because he is significantly stronger like an elf after the Agaetí Blödhren celebration, he can move his sword faster, causing more impacting hits to take place. But Murtagh, his friend, stole Zar'roc, a magically protected sword, form Eragon. The falchion broke after a dwarf used his shield to deflect it. "With a crystalline sound, the blade of the falchion shattered into a dozen pieces, leaving him with a six-inch spike of jagged metal protruding from the hilt." (Paolini 453).

So obviously Eragon was disadvantaged by magical means here. He thought he could sweep by his attackers, but because of his overconfidence and his breakable sword, magic failed and he was almost defeated. This is yet another event where magic is a disadvantage for Eragon and his unfortunate falchion.

Sunday, April 20, 2014

Is Magic What It Appears To Be? #4

In Brisingr, magic plays an important role in defense as well as attacking power. Though one's fists can be very effective in close combat, they don't hold up forever, especially when they are hitting something hard, such as armor. Eragon experiences this when he is facing an enemy soldier. "The fourth soldier was so close by then, running at him with sword held high, Eragon could not evade him. Trapped, he did the one thing he could: he struck the man in the chest with all his might. A fount of blood and sweat erupted as his fist connected. The blow staved in the man's ribs and propelled him more than a dozen feet over the grass, where he fetched up against another corpse." (Paolini 184). Because of the Agaetí Blödhren, or Blood Oath Celebration, the magic allowed Eragon to do impressive feats he was never capable of doing as a regular human. But in this next quote, we see that this type of magic has consequences. "Eragon gasped and doubled over, cradling his throbbing hand. Four of his knuckles were disjointed, and white cartilage showed through his mangled skin. Blast, he though as hot blood poured from the wounds. His fingers refused to move when he ordered them to; he realized that his hand would be useless until he could heal it. Fearing another attack, he looked around for Arya an the rest of the soldiers." (Paolini 184). Because of the magic, Eragon went overboard with his thinking and reasoning of his new abilities, overusing them and causing his hand to be injured. This represents a disadvantage of magic because it caused him to resort to injuring himself, even though he would never think to do such a thing as a regular human.

Magic also has its advantage here. Not only can the magic heal the hand, but it can protect it from further attempts of smashing through armor. "With an effort of will, he stayed where he was and watched as the skin on his knuckles bulged, forming a flat, whitish callus half an inch thick over each joint. They reminded him of the hornlike deposits that appear on the inside of horses' legs. When he was pleased with the size and density of the knobs, he released the flow of magic and set about exploring, by touch and sight, the mountainous new terrain that loomed over his fingers. His hands were heavier and stiffer than before, but he could still move his fingers through their full range of motion. It may be ugly, he thought, rubbing the rough protuberances on his right hand against the palm of his left, and people may laugh and sneer if they notice, but I don't care, for it will serve its purpose and may keep me alive." Magic is shown giving an opportunity for Eragon to fight with greater strength and less worried thoughts about his hand. 

So overall in this situation, magic is advantageous. Though Eragon almost lost his hand in the battle, magic restored his hand afterward and made it stronger/more capable. Someone could argue that without magic, he wouldn't have injured his hand in battle but let's think about this; he would never be able to SURVIVE in battle if he never knew magic. This situation tells us that magic here is disadvantageous for a short moment, but advantageous in the long run because it saved him many injuries and possibly death at an earlier date. 

Here is a link to the Inheritance Cycle website. Read the author's biography, news about the series' success, and even discover more fantasy writers. http://www.alagaesia.com/index.php     

Sunday, April 13, 2014

Is Magic What It Appears To Be? #3

This next example of the advantages/disadvantages of magic comes from the next book in the series, Brisingr. In my opinion, this example is somewhat of an in between-er. It has a very distinct advantage, but depending on how the book plays out, it could have a disadvantaged use.

In Eldest, the previous book, there was this man named Sloan who betrayed the villagers of Carvahall under Roran to the Empire, condemning the villagers to death/enslavement and kidnapping his daughter, Katrina (who was also Roran's bride, much to Sloan's discontent and anger). In Brisingr we find that Sloan is in Helgrind, an important city of the Empire. After Eragon, Saphira, and Roran defeat the Ra'zac and the Lethrblaka, the dreaded guards of the prison, Eragon does something that may bring pain and anguish to Roran and Katrina; he saves Sloan from death and tells Roran he is dead. In this quote, the predicament of the situation is shown and an important decision is made: "I can't kill Sloan, I can't let Roran or Katrina see him, and I can't allow him to starve to death in his cell or Galbatorix's men to recapture him. I'm sorry, but I have to deal with Sloan on my own." (Paolini 62). This statement represents a disadvantaged situation because Eragon once again has to juggle many problems and hold the weight of his secrecy on his shoulders. If Roran finds out about Sloan's survival, Eragon could lose his own brother as an ally, meaning possibly the rest of the Carvahall villagers. Sloan could be at a disadvantage from magic. After Eragon got Roran an Katrina away from Helgrind, he took away Sloan's vision and made him swear magical oaths stating he could never see his daughter Katrina again, only knowing she and Roran are happy together. In this situation, magic is difficult and costly for Eragon as well as tormenting for Sloan.

But on the bright side, this could be advantageous for Sloan as well. Eragon spared his life and sent him to the elves in their city, Ellesméra. They would restore his vision, care for him, and there Sloan could start fresh and get away from his past life. This quote describes the hope Sloan has in the mystical forest of the elves: "The elves will care for you and allow you to do whatever you want for the rest of your life, with one exception: once you enter Du Weldenvarden, you cannot leave....Sloan, listen to me. When I was among the elves, I learned that a person's true name often changes as they age. Do you understand what that means? Who you are is not fixed for all of eternity. A man could forge himself anew if he so wanted." (Paolini 93). Sloan was still in agony after being condemned, but surely enough, he was on his way to the elves in the morning, giving Eragon satisfaction. In this case, magic is hopeful and truly advantageous at giving Sloan another chance and satisfactory for Eragon in finding a way to save Sloan from death.


Sunday, April 6, 2014

Is Magic What It Appears To Be? #2

Another example of magic being used in a negative way can also be seen within Eldest at the Battle of the Burning Plains. Eragon was caught off guard by another Rider whom he thought was dead. It was actually his past friend, Murtagh, who he thought was dead. Murtagh had greater magical abilities and strength than Eragon had learned from Oromis. Murtagh easily defeated him with spells Eragon had never heard of. Magic is disadvantageous in this situation because the more powerful an enemy magician is, the greater the risk of being defeated as the lesser magician, or less powerful. This first quote shows the ease of Eragon vanquishing a magician and the soldiers he controlled; "Bringing the full power of his will to bear, Eragon demolished the magician's resistance, took control of his consciousness-doing his best to ignore the man's terror-determined which troops the man was guarding, and slew the man with one of the twelve words of death. Without pause, Eragon located the minds of each of the now-unprotected soldiers and killed them as well. The Varden cheered as the knot of men went limp." (Paolini 624). In this situation, Eragon had the upper hand with the weaker magician and easily entered his consciousness taking control. Now Murtagh, on the other hand, shows his skill and power in this quote; "As much as he hated it-hated the entire situation, in fact-Eragon knew then what had to be done. Renewing his attack on Murtagh's mind, he leaped forward, both feet leaving the ground as he lunged toward Murtagh, intending to stab him through the heart. 'Letta' barked Murtagh. Eragon dropped back to the ground as invisible hands clamped around his arms and legs, immobilizing him." (Paolini 650). King Galbatorix taught Murtagh destructive spells that could easily crush enemies. Murtagh swore oaths to him so he has no way of breaking free from control. Below is Thorn, Murtagh's dragon.



Magic is also disadvantageous for the enemy in this battle. While magic can be effective, it is seemingly weak against silent, sneaking enemies. The Twins are immensely powerful magicians working for the enemy that could easily match Eragon's skill. But they are killed unusually fast by Eragon's brother, not trained in any magical skill. "Together they watched as Roran hid behind a mound of bodies. Eragon stiffened as the Twins looked toward the pile. For a moment, it seemed they had spotted him, then they turned away and Roran jumped up. He swung his hammer and bashed one of the Twins in the head, cracking open his skull. The remaining Twin fell to the ground, convulsing, and emitted a wordless scream until he too met his end under Roran's hammer. Then Roran planted his foot upon the corpses of his foes, lifted his hammer over his head, and bellowed his victory." (Paolini 648). As stated here, even concealed enemies can kill magicians before they have a chance to defend themselves.