This next example of the advantages/disadvantages of magic comes from the next book in the series, Brisingr. In my opinion, this example is somewhat of an in between-er. It has a very distinct advantage, but depending on how the book plays out, it could have a disadvantaged use.
In Eldest, the previous book, there was this man named Sloan who betrayed the villagers of Carvahall under Roran to the Empire, condemning the villagers to death/enslavement and kidnapping his daughter, Katrina (who was also Roran's bride, much to Sloan's discontent and anger). In Brisingr we find that Sloan is in Helgrind, an important city of the Empire. After Eragon, Saphira, and Roran defeat the Ra'zac and the Lethrblaka, the dreaded guards of the prison, Eragon does something that may bring pain and anguish to Roran and Katrina; he saves Sloan from death and tells Roran he is dead. In this quote, the predicament of the situation is shown and an important decision is made: "I can't kill Sloan, I can't let Roran or Katrina see him, and I can't allow him to starve to death in his cell or Galbatorix's men to recapture him. I'm sorry, but I have to deal with Sloan on my own." (Paolini 62). This statement represents a disadvantaged situation because Eragon once again has to juggle many problems and hold the weight of his secrecy on his shoulders. If Roran finds out about Sloan's survival, Eragon could lose his own brother as an ally, meaning possibly the rest of the Carvahall villagers. Sloan could be at a disadvantage from magic. After Eragon got Roran an Katrina away from Helgrind, he took away Sloan's vision and made him swear magical oaths stating he could never see his daughter Katrina again, only knowing she and Roran are happy together. In this situation, magic is difficult and costly for Eragon as well as tormenting for Sloan.
But on the bright side, this could be advantageous for Sloan as well. Eragon spared his life and sent him to the elves in their city, Ellesméra. They would restore his vision, care for him, and there Sloan could start fresh and get away from his past life. This quote describes the hope Sloan has in the mystical forest of the elves: "The elves will care for you and allow you to do whatever you want for the rest of your life, with one exception: once you enter Du Weldenvarden, you cannot leave....Sloan, listen to me. When I was among the elves, I learned that a person's true name often changes as they age. Do you understand what that means? Who you are is not fixed for all of eternity. A man could forge himself anew if he so wanted." (Paolini 93). Sloan was still in agony after being condemned, but surely enough, he was on his way to the elves in the morning, giving Eragon satisfaction. In this case, magic is hopeful and truly advantageous at giving Sloan another chance and satisfactory for Eragon in finding a way to save Sloan from death.
Very interesting and like how you described the book.
ReplyDeleteGood job describing both sides of magic, good and bad, and using quotes on both sides.
ReplyDeleteI like how you thoroughly analyzed the advantages and disadvantages to the decision of Eragon. This allows people who haven't read the book to understand the book a little bit better.
ReplyDeletei like how you analysed the text and the detail you go into it makes the story more clear
ReplyDelete