Thursday, March 13, 2014

Eldest Analogy

I usually don't post analogies, mainly because they can be so simple and small yet complex and powerful. They have confusing intentions; they can be used to compare characters and themes to simple, everyday actions/objects. Eldest, by Christopher Paolini, has some interesting, yet terrifying analogies. Most of them involve the situations between the Empire, led by King Galbatorix, and the Varden, led by Nasuada. But this special analogy involves the main character and the conflict he has willingly, but unknowingly plunged himself into.

Eragon is the main character. He has magical abilities separate from many other humans and has incredible sword skills. One of his primary weaknesses in the story line is that he consistently makes oaths and swears loyalty to different leaders in the Varden. Thus,

 Eragon : oaths as Swordfish : multiple driftnets.

To tell you the truth, that sounds strange, even for me. Lets dissect it word for word and then it might make more sense.
Eragon somewhat resembles a swordfish. He is strong and not easily taken down by enemies. In other words, he has a lower vulnerability against the Empire's troops (Urgals) than a regular villager. He is unique, as a swordfish is unique to other fish.
Oaths are tricky things to swear and uphold. Oaths, in this situation, are like juggling balls. The balls are similar, respectively, to oaths. The more oaths you have to uphold, the more balls you have to juggle, meaning it gets harder and harder until all of the balls fall to the ground. Now, the idea of all the juggling balls falling to the ground is not a probable representation of oaths. Most likely they will be lost gradually, not all at the exact same time. But for the sake of not going into an entire paragraph of an appropriate, probable depiction and boring you to death, this brief picture will do. In comparison to a swordfish, oaths are like multiple driftnets. Once the swordfish is caught by more than one, it is trapped between multiple people and their intentions. One person may want to let it go (again, not probable with a driftnet), another may want to keep it for food, yet another may want it to study it for scientific reasons. Either way the swordfish is still trapped and can't move

So, the analogy makes sense. Eragon is entangled in his oaths as a swordfish could be entangled in multiple driftnets.

   

5 comments:

  1. Chris, your blogs are very insightful and I love the way you used a complex and confusing analogy and broke it down into more simple ideas to help people understand it. Keep up the great posts.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I thought it was creative to use analogies to compare categories in a book. I must admit, I did not understand it at first, and I thank you for dissecting it. Thanks for this great post!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Great blog post. You used great detail and made it easy for people to understand and follow. Keep up the awesome posts.

    ReplyDelete
  4. That was a great post with the your ability to "dissect" the analogy while still relating back to what it actually was meaning. Your ability to do so helped me to better understand what the analogy referred to. Also the metaphor about juggling balls and dropping them slowly was great for better understanding and imagery.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I have read this book and I agree with the analogy that you made. I think that your explanation would also very helpful to people who would not have read this book.

    ReplyDelete